Is Silver Overvalued?
- ccancino3
- 5 days ago
- 4 min read
Updated: 2 days ago
When an event considered a “historical anomaly” occurs, it is worth pausing and analyzing it carefully. In financial markets, not every move signals continuity; many are, on the contrary, temporary events. Today, silver is sending two rare signals that invite investors to temper expectations.
First Signal: Silver vs. Oil
Since December 2025, one ounce of silver costs more than a barrel of oil for the first time in 45 years. This has happened only once before.
That the price of silver exceeds the price of a barrel of oil is a historical anomaly whose only precedent dates back to the volatile commodities “boom” of the late 1970s and early 1980s.
SILVER PRICE / OIL PRICE
1965 - 2026 (ENE)
During the second half of 2025, Brent crude prices remained in a range of US $60–65 per barrel, while West Texas crude hovered around US $60. On December 10, 2025, silver reached US $60 per ounce for the first time in history.
The last time this crossover occurred, in the early 1980s; the backdrop was runaway inflation, an energy crisis, and deep monetary distrust. It was a brief episode: the silver price rose to 1.1 times the price of a barrel of oil and shortly thereafter collapsed sharply. It was not a new market equilibrium, but rather an excess reflected in an overvalued silver price.
Returning to 2025, this historical anomaly has only intensified at an accelerated pace. Silver surpassed US $100 per ounce for the first time on January 23, 2026, and reached an all-time high of US $117 per ounce on January 26, 2026. This implies that the price of one ounce of silver is now nearly twice the price of a barrel of oil — an unprecedented historical event.
Second Signal: The Gold–Silver Ratio
The gold–silver ratio indicates how many ounces of silver are required to purchase one ounce of gold. Historically, silver prices tend to follow gold prices — a metal that typically moves first — followed by silver, whose price tends to be more volatile, meaning it rises more and falls more than gold.
Given the strong correlation in the price of both metals, the gold–silver ratio is widely used to assess how overvalued (or undervalued) silver is relative to gold. Over the past 10 years, this indicator remained within a range of 65–95, meaning that, on average since 2015, about 80 ounces of silver were required to buy one ounce of gold.
GOLD-SILVER RATIO
2000-2026 (JAN)
From January 2026, the gold–silver ratio fell below 50 — an extraordinarily low level relative to its recent history. At the time of writing this article (Jan 27, 2026), fewer than 50 ounces of silver are needed to purchase one ounce of gold, reflecting exceptional relative strength in silver prices compared to gold.
Such a low gold–silver ratio implies that silver has dramatically outperformed gold. In 2025 alone, silver prices rose nearly 150%, while gold — despite reaching record highs — gained 64%. The first days of 2026 have seen an acceleration of this trend, with silver appreciating an astonishing 57%, while gold has risen a solid 22% (as of Jan 27, 2026).
Historically, such extreme divergences do not tend to persist for long, but instead correct through a reversal in silver prices. The last time the gold–silver ratio reached comparable levels was in 2011, during a speculative silver rally driven by abundant liquidity from post-financial-crisis monetary stimulus, fears of inflation and currency debasement, strong silver demand, and tight physical supply. That move was temporary, with silver losing 30% of its value in a matter of days and the gold–silver ratio returning to its typical range.
Is History Repeating Itself… or Is This Time Different?
Evidence observed during this century shows that a gold–silver ratio below 50 has tended to coincide with episodes of euphoria, marked by extreme silver revaluation and late-cycle enthusiasm in precious metals, making it one of the most powerful — and also most risky — market signals.
On the other hand, there are structural reasons that justify the surge in silver prices: tight physical supply and rapidly expanding demand. Reports show that global silver mine production has stagnated, while recycling cannot bridge the gap, leading to persistent market deficits — projected at 95 to 149 million ounces for 2025 alone — marking the fifth consecutive year of shortages and driving inventories to multi-decade lows. In addition, the accelerated loss of value of the U.S. dollar since early 2026 has acted as fuel, boosting the revaluation of gold prices — and, by extension, silver.
In conclusion, the structural value of silver as a precious metal and its role as an industrial input are not in question. However, current data suggest that silver may be entering a zone of tactical risk, comparable to past episodes that ultimately proved to be extreme and temporary moves. Investing with a long-term, wealth-preservation mindset means knowing when to advance and when to observe. And today, silver prices suggest caution.
Protect your Savings
Aktagold helps individuals worldwide protect their wealth from economic instability by providing access to savings in physical gold, stored in high-security vaults at the Royal Canadian Mint® in Ottawa (Canada), offering a level of protection once reserved for the wealthiest investors.
Start Saving in Gold
